| Wt | Winner | Result | Loser | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 125 | #23 Sulayman Bah · Columbia | DEC 9-6 Decision | #25 Davis Motyka · Pennsylvania | confirmed |
| 133 | #22 Evan Mougalian · Pennsylvania | DEC 7-0 Decision | #39 Evin Gursoy · Columbia | confirmed |
| 141 | #9 CJ Composto · Pennsylvania | DEC 8-4 Decision | #31 Lorenzo Frezza · Columbia | confirmed |
| 149 | #6 Cross Wasilewski · Pennsylvania | DEC 9-3 Decision | Richard Fedalen | one source |
| 157 | #10 Jude Swisher · Pennsylvania | MD 14-1 Major decision | #16 Kai Owen · Columbia | confirmed |
| 165 | #5 Cesar Alvan · Columbia | DEC 4-1 Decision | #19 Sean Seefeldt · Pennsylvania | confirmed |
| 174 | #14 Nick Fine · Columbia | MD 13-5 Major decision | Lance Urbas | confirmed |
| 184 | #28 Joe Curtis · Columbia | MD 16-4 Major decision | Liam Carlin | confirmed |
| 197 | #35 Jack Wehmeyer · Columbia | DEC 4-1 Decision | #51 Martin Cosgrove · Pennsylvania | confirmed |
| 285 | #18 Vincent Mueller · Columbia | FALL Fall | #62 John Vinciguerra · Pennsylvania | one source |
Results for 2025-26 come from the schools' own box scores and from tournament brackets imported by hand, through Jan 24, 2026. A dual whose page printed no box score, or an open that was not exported, is missing here. Bouts against non-Division I opponents are listed but not counted in records.How ScrapStat counts.